It’s safe to say that the biggest competitor brands of Bayliner are Tahoe, Hurricane, Starcraft, Stingray, and Carolina Skiff.
If you want to compare the boats built by these manufacturers with the latest Bayliner boats, you are in the right place.
We at PowerSportsGuide compared them head-to-head by the numbers!
Which Boats Are Comparable to Bayliner Elements?
Bayliner Element M15
If you are looking for Bayliner Element alternatives, you should take a look at the fleets of Tahoe, Starcraft, Stingray, and Hurricane.
While the entire Bayliner Element series is built on the patented M-hulls, the competitors still feature a V-shaped hull design.
The smallest Bayliner in this breed is the Element M15. Although this boat is the only 15-footer deck boat in the marketplace, its direct competitor could be the 16-footer Tahoe T16.
Comparison Chart:
| Model | Length (ft.) | People Capacity | Max HP | Dry Weight |
| Bayliner Element M15 | 15’2″ | 5 | 50 HP | 1,385 lbs. |
| Tahoe T16 | 16’5″ | 6 | 75 HP | 1,500 lbs. |
Bayliner Element M17
As the name suggests, the Element Bayliner M17 is built on a 17-foot M-shaped hull. It can be opted with either a 60, 75, or 90hp Mercury outboard.
Rival deck boats in this class are the Stingray 172SC and the Starcraft SVX 171 OB. The latter comes with a remarkable people capacity of 10.
Comparison Chart:
| Model | Length (ft.) | People Capacity | Max HP | Dry Weight |
| Element M17 | 17’0″ | 7 | 90 HP | 1,984 lbs. |
| Stingray 172SC | 17’3″ | 7 | 90 HP | 1,900 lbs. |
| Starcraft SVX 171 OB | 17’4″ | 10 | 115 HP | 2,126 lbs. |
Bayliner Element E18
When it comes to the 18-footer class, one of the biggest competitors of the Bayliner Element E18 is arguably the Tahoe T18.
They are not only of the same weight, but both can also carry a crew of 9 with ease.
Comparison Chart:
| Model | Length (ft.) | Max People Capacity | Max HP | Dry Weight |
| Bayliner Element E18 | 18’2″ | 9 | 125 HP | 2,000 lbs. |
| Tahoe T18 | 18’5″ | 9 | 115 HP | 1,940 lbs. |
Bayliner Element M19
Worthy competitors of the 19-footer Element M19 are the Stingray 182SC, the Starcraft SVX 191 OB, and the Hurricane Sundeck Sport 188 OB.
Each of these boats comes with a 19-foot hull and various outboard engine options.
Comparison Chart:
| Model | Length (ft.) | People Capacity | Max HP | Dry Weight |
| Bayliner Element M19 | 19′ | 9 | 115 HP | 2,399 lbs. |
| Stingray 182SC | 19’1′ | 9 | 115 HP | 2,050 lbs. |
| Starcraft SVX 191 OB | 18’11” | 12 | 150 HP | 2,378 lbs. |
| Hurricane Sundeck Sport 188 OB | 18’10” | 10 | 200 HP | 2,425 lbs. |
Element E21
Based on our research, the closest competitors of the Bayliner Element E21 are the Starcraft SVX 211 OB, Hurricane Sundeck Sport 201 OB, and the Stingray 192 SC.
Like the Bayliner, the latter can carry a crew of 10, while the others can carry 14 and 12 people, respectively.
Comparison Chart:
| Model | Length (ft.) | People Capacity | Max HP | Dry Weight |
| Bayliner Element E21 | 20’8″ | 10 | 150 HP | 2,645 lbs. |
| Starcraft SVX 211 OB | 20’9″ | 14 | 200 HP | 2,685 lbs. |
| Stingray 192 SC | 20’1″ | 10 | 200 HP | 2,700 lbs. |
| Hurricane Sundeck Sport 201 OB | 20’1′ | 12 | 200 HP | 2,475 lbs. |
What are the Alternatives to the Bayliner DX Deck Boats?
Bayliner DX2000
The closest competitor of the Bayliner DX2000 outboard is the Tahoe 1950 since these boats come with very similar capacities and features.
We also have to mention the popular Hurricane Sundeck 218 OB.
Even though this boat is slightly shorter, it’s still rated at 10 people.
Compared to the Bayliner and the Tahoe, this model is significantly lighter and can be opted with a 200hp outboard.
Comparison Chart:
| Model | Length (ft.) | People Capacity | Max HP | Dry Weight |
| Bayliner DX2000 | 19’7″ | 10 | 150 HP | 2,810 lbs. |
| Tahoe 1950 | 19’5″ | 10 | 175 HP | 3,135 lbs. |
| Hurricane Sundeck 218 OB | 18’10” | 10 | 200 HP | 2,450 lbs. |
Bayliner DX2050
The Bayliner DX2050 is the sterndrive variation of the popular DX2000.
In this class, one of the closest rivals to the Bayliner is the Hurricane Sundeck Sport 205 IO.
Both of these boats weigh around 3,500-3,600 pounds and are available with a 250hp MerCruiser sterndrive engine.
Comparison Chart:
| Model | Length (ft.) | People Capacity | Max HP | Dry Weight |
| Bayliner DX2050 IO | 19’7″ | 9 | 250 HP | 3,497 lbs. |
| Hurricane Sundeck Sport 205 IO | 20’9″ | 10 | 250 HP | 3,600 lbs. |
Bayliner DX2200
Flagship Bayliner deck boats are arguably the DX2200/DX2250. The former can be rigged with Mercury outboards with a maximum engine power of 225hp.
Worthy competitors of this boat are the Hurricane SunDeck 217 OB, the Tahoe 2150, and the Stingray 212SC.
Comparison Chart:
| Model | Length (ft.) | People Capacity | Max HP | Dry Weight |
| Bayliner DX2200 OB | 21’7″ | 12 | 225 HP | 3,805 lbs. |
| Hurricane SunDeck 217 OB | 21’5″ | 14 | 225 HP | 2,700 lbs. |
| Tahoe 2150 | 21’1″ | 11 | 225 HP | 3,235 lbs. |
| Stingray 212SC | 21’11” | 12 | 200 HP | 3,100 lbs. |
Bayliner DX2250
The Bayliner DX2250 is available with either 200hp or 250hp MerCruiser sterndrive engines.
If you are looking for an alternative to this model, you may want to take a close look at the Starcraft SVX IO 210.
Compared to the Bayliner, this boat is significantly lighter and comes with slightly larger capacities.
Comparison Chart:
| Model | Length (ft.) | People Capacity | Max HP | Dry Weight |
| Bayliner DX2250 | 21’7″ | 11 | 350 HP | 3,999 lbs. |
| Starcraft SVX IO 210 | 21’5″ | 12 | 250 HP | 3,378 lbs. |
What are the Alternatives to the Bayliner VR Bowriders?
Bayliner VR4
Among the 19-footer bowriders, the Bayliner VR4 competes with the Tahoe 185S.
Despite its dual console architecture, the Stingray 191DC is also a worthy option to consider in this class.
This boat comes standard with a windshield and can accommodate 9 people due to its roomier deck space.
Comparison Chart:
| Model | Length (ft.) | People Capacity | Max HP | Dry Weight |
| Bayliner VR4 Bowrider OB | 18’9″ | 7 | 150 HP | 2,822 lbs. |
| Tahoe 185 S | 18’5″ | 8 | 150 HP | 2,270 lbs. |
| Stingray 191DC | 19’1″ | 9 | 115 HP | 2,000 lbs. |
Bayliner VR5
Like in the lower class, in the 21-footer category, we can also find the Bayliner VR5 Bowrider competing with the Tahoe 210S.
These can be fitted with outboard motors with a maximum power of 250 and 225hp, respectively.
And here’s the slightly smaller, 20-footer Stingray 201DC dual console. It can carry a group of 10 and can be fitted with an outboard up to 200hp.
Comparison Chart:
| Model | Length (ft.) | People Capacity | Max HP | Dry Weight |
| Bayliner VR5 Bowrider OB | 20’7″ | 9 | 250 HP | 3,342 lbs. |
| Tahoe 210S | 21’5″ | 10 | 225 HP | 3,225 lbs. |
| Stingray 201DC | 20’1″ | 10 | 200 HP | 2,900 lbs. |
Bayliner VR6
It’s safe to say that one of the closest competitors of the Bayliner VR6 outboard is the Stingray 211DC.
Although the latter is almost a foot shorter, it’s much lighter and can carry a larger crew thanks to its deck boat origins. On top of that, it can be rigged with a more powerful outboard motor.
Comparison Chart:
| Model | Length (ft.) | People Capacity | Max HP | Dry Weight |
| Bayliner VR6 Bowrider OB | 22’7″ | 10 | 200 HP | 3,797 lbs. |
| Stingray 211DC | 21’8″ | 12 | 225 HP | 3,248 lbs. |
The Bayliner VR6 I/O is the sterndrive equivalent to the VR6 Outboard.
This boat is comparable to the Starcraft SVX IO 230 dual console deck boat, which is a bit larger in dimensions and can carry a crew of 14.
Comparison Chart:
| Model | Length (ft.) | People Capacity | Max HP | Dry Weight |
| Bayliner VR6 Bowrider | 22’7″ | 10 | 250 HP | 3,797 lbs. |
| Starcraft SVX IO 230 | 23’4″ | 14 | 300 HP | 3,658 lbs. |
What are the Alternatives to the Bayliner Trophy Fishing Boats?
Trophy T18Bay
The Bayliner Trophy T18Bay is released as the smallest fishing Bayliner. This center console boat is built on the 18-footer M-hull and can be rigged with a Mercury outboard up to 115hp.
Competitor models in this breed include the Carolina Skiff 19 Ultra Elite and the slightly smaller Stingray 173CC.
You can expect the dry weight of these boats to be in the ballpark of 2,000-2,266 pounds.
Comparison Chart:
| Model | Length (ft.) | People Capacity | Max HP | Dry Weight |
| Bayliner Trophy T18Bay | 18’2″ | 6 | 115 HP | 2,000 lbs. |
| Stingray 173CC | 17’3″ | 7 | 90 HP | 2,100 lbs. |
| Carolina Skiff 19 Ultra Elite | 18’11” | 10 | 150 HP | 2,266 lbs. |
Trophy T21Bay
The Bayliner T21Bay is the bigger brother of the entry-level T18Bay.
It features a 21-footer M-hull, center console deck architecture, and can be fitted with Mercury outboards up to 150hp.
There are many great alternatives to this boat, and some of them are the Stingray 206CC and the Carolina Skiff 21 LS.
Comparison Chart:
| Model | Length (ft.) | People Capacity | Max HP | Dry Weight |
| Bayliner Trophy T21Bay | 20’8″ | 10 | 150 HP | 2,645 lbs. |
| Stingray 206CC | 20’1″ | 9 | 200 HP | 2,700 lbs. |
| Carolina Skiff 21 LS | 21’1″ | 10 | 175 HP | 2,100 lbs. |
Bayliner Trophy T22CC
Unlike the “Bay” series, the Bayliner T22CC is built on a standard deep-V hull.
Even though they are slightly smaller and lighter, the Mako 214CC and the Stingray 216CC come with very similar capacities.
Comparison Chart:
| Model | Length (ft.) | People Capacity | Max HP | Dry Weight |
| Bayliner Trophy T22CC | 22’7″ | 10 | 300 HP | 4,000 lbs. |
| Mako 214CC | 21’5″ | 10 | 250 HP | 3,735 lbs. |
| Stingray 216CC | 21’8″ | 10 | 225 HP | 3,150 lbs. |
Trophy T24CC
The flagship Bayliner fishing boat is the Trophy T24CC, which can be fitted with Mercury outboards up to 300hp.
Competitors of this Bayliner are the Stingray 236CC and the Carolina Skiff 23 LS.
Although each of them can accommodate 12 people, the latter is significantly lighter and has a flatter tri-V hull design. Due to these features, the Carolina Skiff 23 LS is less seaworthy than the other two models.
Comparison Chart:
| Model | Length (ft.) | People Capacity | Max HP | Dry Weight |
| Bayliner Trophy T24CC | 24′ | 12 | 300 HP | 4,466 lbs. |
| Carolina Skiff 23 LS | 23’2″ | 12 | 200 HP | 2,550 lbs. |
| Stingray 236CC | 23’8″ | 12 | 300 HP | 3,648 lbs. |
Which Boats are Comparable to Bayliners? [Chart]
For a better comparison, we listed some of the most common Bayliner competitors in one chart:
| Model | Alternatives |
| Element M15 | Tahoe T16 |
| Element M17 | Stingray 172SC |
| Starcraft SVX 171 OB | |
| Element E18 | Tahoe T18 |
| Hurricane Sundeck Sport 188 OB | |
| Element M19 | Stingray 182SC |
| Starcraft SVX 191 OB | |
| Element E21 | Stingray 192 SC |
| Starcraft SVX 211 OB | |
| Hurricane Sundeck Sport 201 OB | |
| DX2000 OB | Hurricane Sundeck 218 OB |
| DX2050 | Hurricane Sundeck Sport 205 IO |
| DX2250 | Starcraft SVX IO 210 |
| DX2200 | Hurricane SunDeck 217 OB |
| Tahoe 2150 | |
| Stingray 212SC | |
| VR4 Bowrider OB | Tahoe 185 S |
| Stingray 191DC | |
| VR5 Bowrider OB | Tahoe 210S |
| Stingray 201DC | |
| VR6 Bowrider OB | Stingray 211DC |
| VR6 Bowrider | Starcraft SVX IO 230 |
| Trophy T18Bay | Stingray 173CC |
| Carolina Skiff 19 Ultra Elite | |
| Trophy T21Bay | Stingray 206CC |
| Carolina Skiff 21 LS | |
| Trophy T22CC | Mako 214CC |
| Stingray 216CC | |
| Trophy T24CC | Carolina Skiff 23 LS |
| Stingray 236CC |
Takeaways
When it comes to deck boats and bowriders, the best alternatives to Bayliner boats are Tahoe, Hurricane, Stingray, and Starcraft boats.
Regarding the center console class, some of the major competitors are Stingray, Carolina Skiff, and Mako.
But generally speaking, each of these manufacturers produces solid boats, so you can’t go wrong with any of them!
References:
bayliner, tahoeboats, stingrayboats, starcraftmarine, hurricaneboats, carolinaskiff, makoboats
